I have had numerous questions about what is ok to let young girls read. Honestly, I have no idea what is ok for your teenager, but I do know that my own mother was fairly open-minded in what she let me read. This list of books may reflect that open-mindedness.
I will give you one clue, though. Check between the mattresses if you are suspicious you aren’t seeing everything your girl brings home from the library.
Raise your hand if you know what I’m talking about. I personally know a few of you that did this, so I expect to see at least three hands in the comment section. Four if you count mine.
Here is a list that Liz and I compiled. We have not personally read every single one of these books, but we have it from good sources that they are good books. Always do your own checking, though, and please don’t blame us if they don’t meet your personal criterea! 😉

Here’s the list:
Vinegar Girl – Anne Tyler
Rose Cottage – Mary Stewart
Mara, Daughter of the Nile; Master Cornhill; The Chalice; Sawdust in His Shoes; – Eloise Jarvis McGraw
Life of Pi – Yann Martel
In His Steps – George Sheldon
The Lighted Heart – Elizabeth Yates
Pay it Forward – Young Reader’s Version
Flint’s Gift; Flint’s Truth; Flint’s Honor – Richard S. Wheeler
The Virginian – Owen Wister
Around the World in 80 Days – Jules Verne
The Pit – Reginald Maddock
Shane – Jack Schaeffer
Kisses From Katie – Katie J Davis
My Name is Malala -Malala Yousafzai
The Boys in the Boat – Daniel James Brown
The True Confesions of Charlotte Doyle – Avi (I read this one many times when I was about 15)
God’s Smuggler – Brother Andrew
Piecing Me together – Renee Watson
Bud, Not Buddy – Christopher Paul Curtis
The Watson’s go to Birmingham – 1963 – Christopher Paul Curtis
The Charlatans Boy – Jonathon Rogers
The Screwtape Letters – CS Lewis
Echo; Esperanza Rising; The Dreamer – Pam Munoz Ryan
The Boundless – Kenneth Oppel
Fever 1973 – Laurie Halse Anderson
An American Plague: The True and Terrifying Story of the Yellow Fever Epidemic of 1793 – Jim Murphy
The Giver; Gathering Blue; Messenger; Son – Lois Lowry (I read this set a few years ago. A little creepy, but very interesting)
The Goose Girl; Enna Burning; River Secrets; Forest born; Princess Acadamy – Shannon Hale
The first few books of the Brotherband Series by John Flanangan. Further in the series may not be appropriate.
Hattie Big Sky; Hattie Ever After – Kirby Lawson
A Fall of Marigolds – Susan Meissner
The Hiding Place – Corrie Ten Boom
The Witch of Blackbird Pond -Elizabeth Speare (Another favorite of mine. I read it again awhile back and it was just as good!)
Unbroken – Yound adult adaptation
Pride and Prejudice – Jane Austen
The Three Muskateers – Alexandre Dumas
To Kill a Mockingbird – Harper Lee
Moby Dick – Herman Mellville
Gulliver’s Travels – Tom Swift
Great Expectations – Charles Dickens (This one is a great classic. A mansion. A heartbroken lady. Intrigue.)
Mallory Towers series – Enid Blyton (This set takes place at a boarding school. The story is about school life and the antics the girls get up to. Innocent fun)
Some of the Jeanette Oke books (you be the judge)
If you don’t feel like reading every book before you let your child read it, go to goodreads.com and read some reviews on the book. Reading a few reviews could give you a good picture of what is in the book and that will help you know if it’s good material for your daughter (or son).

The following suggestions are from a post on my status asking for book suggestion. They are either what they will allow their teenage daughter to read or what they remember reading at that age. I can’t vouch for all of these suggestions, but I have read lots of them and heartily agree that they are good options!
Authors that were mentioned (a lot of these more than once!):
Jean Stratton Porter
LM Montgomery (duh)
John Flanagan (start with the Brotherband series)
James Herriot
Alber Payson Terhune (The Lad books, some short stories)
Frank Gilbreth (another duh)
Walt Morley
Walter Farley
Jim Kjelgaard
Gordon Korman (my personal least favorite. Too much disrespect)
Lousia May Alcott
Marguerite Henry
Hilda Stahl
Lois Walfrid Johnson
Cheney Duvall
Gilbert Morris ( I really enjoyed the The House of Winslow series when I was in my teens)
Christmas Carol Kauffman
Specific books mentioned:
Riding Freedom and Paint the Wind – Pam Munoz Ryan
The Chronicals of Narnia – CS Lewis
Hope Rising and A Bridge Called Hope – Kim Meeder
Dawn’s Early Light and Yankee Stranger – Elswyth Thayne
Miracles on Maple Hill – Virginia Sorenson
The Emily books – LM Montgomery
Mr Popper’s Penguins -Richard Atwater
The Circle Trilogy – Ted Dekker
Nancy Drew - Carolyn Keen
Hardy Boys – Frank Dixon
Babysitter’s Club – Ann M. Martin (I might stick with the older books in the series)
The Three Investigator books (Amen!! These are so fun) – different authors, just search The Three Investigaters
The Healer’s Apprentice – Melanie Dickerson (and others by this author)
The Blue Castle – LM Montgomery
Daddy Long Legs – Jean Webster
The Scarlet Pimpernel – Baroness Orczy
Whew! That should keep everyone reading for a good long while. Let us know what were favorite books of yours as a teenager. Another question I would like answered is if you use the local library? If so, how do you go about making sure you (or your children) are checking out good wholesome books?
-Eva
(Picture credit: The Besotted Bookworm)


8 responses to “Great Books for the Young Teenage Girl”
🙋🏼♀️🫣
One down 🤣🤣
I read and reread books as a teenager, because our home library was very small. The only other outlet for books I had was the school library or borrowing from friends. A favorite set of books from those days were The Mystifying Twins and The Secret of The Mystifying Twins by Joan Price Reeve. They seem to be very rare books and I’m still waiting to get my hands on a copy of each without having to pay an arm and leg. A couple more I really liked were Tisha and Mrs Mike. I was also into stories about nurses, especially those exciting stories of girls in nursing schools living together and all their adventures; can’t remember any specific titles right off.
I was just telling my girls about The Mystifying Twins the other day. I wish I could find a copy for them!
Thanks for all the suggestions. Never had daughters but have granddaughters. I loved Rachel by Agnes Scott Kent.
This is my reading category even as an adult! Here are some of my favorites from days of yore that I didn’t see on your list.
Zane Grey’s Ken Ward books
John F. Hays (Canadian history)
Coach Claire Bee
Scott Young (has bad language)
The Brains Benton mysteries
Eric Walters Camp X series
Not sure if all girls would enjoy these books but maybe there are those looking for boys YA books. 🙂
I’m just an old retired person so can’t contribute much to this one, but I sure like the pictures you include 😀 And I still use the library a lot.
Glad they bring you joy, Cynthia!